How the Barnum Effect Can Help Professional Service Brands Attract a Larger Audience

September 14, 2023

Ever find yourself nodding along to a generic horoscope, intrigued by how accurately it seems to decipher your life? Or maybe you've been amazed by a fortune cookie that appears to "get you."

That, my friends, is the brilliance of the Barnum Effect.

This psychological phenomenon works its magic by using vague, generalized statements that feel incredibly personalized, as if they're written just for you.

It's like catching a glimpse of your reflection in a still pond—generic on the surface but deeply resonant within.

Now, imagine harnessing this cosmic trick in the realm of marketing and branding your insurance agency or accounting and financial firm?

What if you could craft your brand message so skillfully that it speaks to a diverse audience yet resonates with each individual, much like those enigmatic horoscopes?

The Power of General Specificity

Example: Coca-Cola’s 'Open Happiness' Campaign

For those unfamiliar, the Barnum Effect operates on the principle of general specificity. Sounds like an oxymoron, right? But that's the beauty of it.

The idea is to craft a message broad enough to apply to many, yet specific enough to feel personalized.

Take, for instance, Coca-Cola's iconic 'Open Happiness' campaign. At first glance, it might seem like a broad stroke—after all, who doesn't want to "open happiness"?

But that's precisely the point. By tapping into a universal desire for joy, belonging, and those cherished moments of simple pleasure, Coca-Cola managed to move past the product itself.

The message was wide in its reach, but the sentiment hit home in a very personal way. Each can of soda transitioned from being just a beverage to a little vessel of happiness, waiting to be opened.

In short, it wasn't just about quenching thirst; it was about fulfilling a deeper emotional need.

Don't Just Aim, Impact!

Example: Dove’s 'Real Beauty' Campaign

Here's the catch: when we talk about generalities in the context of the Barnum Effect, we're not referring to messages that are irrelevant or hollow. Quite the opposite, in fact.

The magic happens when a message is so universally relatable that it transforms into something extraordinarily specific for each person. Take Dove's 'Real Beauty' campaign as a prime example.

At its core, the campaign championed the concept of 'Real Beauty,' speaking to every woman—or man, for that matter—who has ever felt the societal pressures of conventional attractiveness. Yet, it did so while making an incredibly poignant statement about body positivity and self-acceptance.

The brilliance here is the campaign's ability to move past generic obstacles and strike at the very core of individual needs and insecurities. In doing so, Dove didn't just sell soap; it offered a genuine solution to a deeply ingrained societal issue.

So, when you aim to make an impact that captures the hearts and minds of your audience, meet them exactly where they are.

Every Wednesday at 11am, BelMarketing Design Studio CEO, Ali J. Taylor—a StoryBrand Certified Guide and Business Made Simple Coach—will share simple marketing principles proven to engage customers and grow businesses. You’ll walk away knowing how to captivate your customers and compel them to buy. So you can stop worrying about your marketing and get back to running the profitable business you dreamed of. Click here to reserve your seat »

Freedom to Adapt

Example: LEGO's Built-in Adaptability

The ingenuity of leveraging the Barnum Effect in marketing lies in its built-in adaptability, much like LEGO's universal system of interlocking bricks. LEGO began with the simple promise encapsulated in their motto: "Only the best is good enough."

This message serves as a foundational "brick," so to speak, upon which the brand has built numerous product lines, from classic building sets to video games, movies, and even theme parks.

What's fascinating here is that LEGO's core message of quality and creativity remains evergreen. It speaks to parents looking for educational toys, collectors seeking intricate models, and even corporations investing in LEGO Serious Play workshops for team building.

The broad message appeals to a diverse demographic, yet the feeling it evokes is highly personal. It resonates with the child lost in imagination, the adult rediscovering a forgotten passion, or the team leader aiming to foster creativity.

In this way, LEGO utilizes the Barnum Effect beautifully. They offer a universal yet personally resonant message, allowing them the freedom to adapt and expand their offerings without overhauling their brand identity.

Essentially, they've created a brand that's as versatile and imaginative as the very blocks they sell.

Building Community Through Resonance

Example: Nike’s 'Just Do It' Slogan

When you hit that universal note, building a community becomes less of an uphill battle and more of a downhill glide. Let's take a moment to unpack Nike's iconic "Just Do It" slogan.

On the surface, it appears to be a clarion call for athletes, urging them to break records and smash personal bests. But dive a bit deeper, and you'll find it's so much more—it's a mantra for life.

The slogan speaks to anyone with a dream to chase, a goal to achieve, or even a simple task to accomplish. It could be the aspiring writer battling writer's block, the entrepreneur taking their first step, or the parent balancing work and family life.

By focusing not just on athletes but on the universal human drive to move past obstacles and achieve, Nike cast not just a wide net, but the right one. This net, carefully woven with the threads of ambition, determination, and resilience, ensnares those who are authentically aligned with Nike's brand values.

This is the epitome of using the Barnum Effect the right way in branding. Nike's message is general enough to bring diverse individuals under one umbrella but specific enough to deeply resonate and inspire action, thereby creating a community that is as loyal as it is varied.

Action Steps

  1. Audit your messaging: Does it resonate broadly yet still impact deeply?

  2. Flex your adaptability: Can your messaging pivot to meet emerging client needs without losing its core essence?

  3. Measure resonance: Are you building a community that's aligned with your brand values?

So, the next time you're brainstorming that killer campaign, remember: the stars might be vague, but they sure do know how to shine.

How can your brand do the same?


About The Wednesday Wisdom Series

Unless you've discovered the secret to everlasting life, you don't have enough time to learn everything there is to learn about how to grow and scale your business on your own.

The Wednesday Wisdom Series is where experienced professionals share their wisdom on running, growing, and scaling a business.